Monday, February 14, 2011

The Lottery


            Dwayne was one of five contestants.
They sat, waiting for what was inevitable.
            They were finalists; one of them would win.
            “Where are you going to go if you win?” the old woman asked.
            “Atlanta,” Dwayne said.  “What about you?”
            “Boston,” she said.
            “I’m heading to Toronto,” the young woman said.  She was confident at first, then became reserved when she saw the collective reaction of her competitors.
            “Hopefully…”
            Dwayne looked at the book the middle-aged man next to him was reading.  It was not familiar.  The man looked up and saw the question on Dwayne’s face.
            “It’s about a man who burns books.  It’s set in the future.  The man is a fireman – he starts fires instead of putting them out.”
            Dwayne smiled and nodded.  He’d lost interest after the man said it was set in the future – the present was all that mattered to Dwayne.  He was focused on his chances of winning.
            “Where you hoping to go?” Dwayne asked, mostly in an effort to cover the fact that he hadn’t been listening.
“Seattle,” the man mumbled.  He must have known that he had the least chance of winning this lottery.  Seattle was the destination that was furthest from where they sat.
“Oh,” Dwayne said to him sympathetically.  “That’s rough.”
He turned away and watched the young woman wipe her daughter’s mouth.
“You have to use your napkin, Sweetie,” she said.
He looked down at the little girl’s half-eaten slice of pepperoni pizza and recalled his own pseudo-Italian treat with a shudder.  The airport parlor professed to serve it New York style, but it was more like freezer-burned then re-heated grocery store brand pizza.
As they sat there, in silence, waiting for the announcement, a bond seemed to form.  Suddenly, Dwayne cared about the middle-aged man getting to Seattle.  The young woman wanted the old woman’s trip to Boston to take place.  And the little girl – the little girl offered him a bite of her cold pepperoni pizza.
(He took it.)
It was then, after the forming of the bond, that Dwayne began to calculate.  The eyes of his friends/opponents told him they were doing the same.

The old woman could not win.  Society did not care enough about her.  She would wait all night and no one would offer her as much as a stale donut or even a cup of bad coffee.
The young woman would have been a shoo-in if she were prettier.  She had intelligence in her eyes, no streaks in her natural blond hair, breasts large enough to be noticeable, but not so big as to seem augmented.  But the child and the conspicuously absent wedding ring destroyed the image of perfection she may have had and cast a disparaging shadow upon her.  If she were prettier, the kid wouldn’t matter.
So, as he saw it, it was between himself the other man.  These things are supposed to be random, but Dwayne knew better.
Once he had dismissed the ladies, Dwayne turned his attention to his remaining competition.  The man was already looking at him.  Apparently he and Dwayne had drawn the same conclusion about the rest of their competition.  The man gave Dwayne a passive once-over and turned away grinning: he thought he’d won
Dwayne, for his part, was more meticulous.  He studied his competitor thoroughly:
The man’s clothes were immaculate.  The contestants had been waiting (im)patiently for several hours already, yet somehow the man’s tan slacks maintained their crease.  The man had downed three cups of coffee (that Dwayne had seen), yet his jacket remained spotless.  The man’s briefcase was real leather; his watch was a real Rolex; his ring had a real diamond in it.
Dwayne was not dressed so impressively.  He had come to the event presumptuously expecting to travel, so he’s dressed for travel: loose-fitting sweat pants, a long sleeve t-shirt and a sideways turned baseball cap.  His authentic Movado watch was hidden by his sleeves because he hadn’t purchased the watch for them – he’d bought it for himself.
The man was an obviously successful late middle-aged White man.  The man proudly wore his fraternity ring in lieu of a wedding band.  The man’s wing tip shoes reflected a glare into Dwayne’s retina that made Dwayne want to shade his eyes.
But he didn’t.
He didn’t because Dwayne didn’t want to deceive the man into thinking he was intimidated by the man’s dapper appearance.  He wasn’t intimidated because he’d spotted the chink in the man’s armor.
The white man’s hair piece was slightly, but noticeably, off-center.  Though it may be considered a minor oversight by some, it represented dual shortcomings.
First, it represented the man’s need to fit in with what was expected of him.  The hair piece represented a fear of not fitting in.  It was not a fear that Dwayne shared.
The second shortcoming represented was the ability to make a major oversight.  With a hairpiece, a few inches to the left can be so noticeable as to become excruciating to witness.
Besides – a real Rolex, a real diamond, real leather… fake hair?  Authenticity cannot be purchased.
By Dwayne’s calculations, he’d won.
And the best part was, the man didn’t know.  (How quickly presumed friendship becomes even the slightest modicum of animosity when the opportunity presents itself to prove someone wrong.)

A voice came over the loudspeaker.
“Attention passengers.”
They held their collective breath.
“Now boarding flight 1265, service to Atlanta.”
“Yes!” Dwayne celebrated.
Forgetting himself for a moment, Dwayne began to dance MC Hammer-style directly in front of his defeated competition.  After a few moments he remembered the silent pact they’d made a few minutes earlier to support whoever won and to hope for the best for everyone else.
Discontinuing his happy-go-lucky jig, Dwayne picked up his carry-on bag and walked to the terminal.
He cast one last look at his single-serving friends as he reached the door.
“Adios, compadres.  Chalk one up for the Black race.”
“We won, Mama?” the little girl asked her mother a little too soon.
Dwayne was still in earshot, but because he was consumed with thoughts of his apparent victory he heard nothing.
When she was sure the Black man was too far to hear, the young mother answered her daughter.
“Yes, Baby, we won.  We always win.”

130 comments:

  1. How do you know that this character is a black male?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Why would the mother think that "we always win" when obviously she didnt win?

    ReplyDelete
  3. Is it possible that the young woman secretly wanted the black man off the train, being the reason why she said she won?

    ReplyDelete
  4. @ Conner: Since the story says "the black man" I think it's safe to assume that he really is a black man.

    ReplyDelete
  5. @ Jennifer: I believe she had another idea in her mind, thus being why in her opinion, she won.

    ReplyDelete
  6. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  7. @ Jennifer: I think that the mother was teaching her daughter to think lesser of black people; that whatever race the mother and the daughter were(I am thinking White)that they are far superior then other races. Meaning that whatever they go through, they are more accepted by society than people of color, and will receive special treatment due to the color or their skin.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Why did Dwayne find it important to calculate his chances of "winning" by studying the people that were around him?

    ReplyDelete
  9. @Abigail: It is possible to assume that the woman did want the man away from her because, at the end when she told her daughter that they won, I assumed that she felt uncomfortable sitting near the man, and that she wanted him to leave.

    ReplyDelete
  10. @ Robert: In every competition a competitor tries to size up his opponents as they are the only things preventing him from winning. Thus it was important for him to know what stood in his way.

    ReplyDelete
  11. How is Dwayne's judgement of his competition similar to the way society judges them? Is it then a coincidence that all the women were disregarded almost immediately?

    ReplyDelete
  12. @ Abigal: It is possible that she wanted the black man off the train. However she could just be not willing to accept that a black man won. Even though she might have wanted the black man gone I believe she would have preferred to "win" the flight as was the goal of everyone there.

    ReplyDelete
  13. What evidence shows that women are being disregarded?

    ReplyDelete
  14. Could the woman be Black herself? Is that why she identified with the Black man by telling her daughter they won?

    ReplyDelete
  15. @ Richard: Society views women as submissive and weak. These views aren't just for women but for anybody they find is weak competition such as an old lady or an unintelligent individual. They automatically disqualify the weak link and focus on stiff competition in every aspect of life.

    ReplyDelete
  16. @ Connor: in general women are disregarded in many ways. One example is in spite of Hilary Clinton running for the position of president, she didn't win over Obama. They chose a BLACK man over a Caucasian woman. In the story Dwayne described how the young woman didn't meet society's standards of beauty so she would of been dropped.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Is it because of Dwayne's race that the other contestants did not support him winning?

    ReplyDelete
  18. @Connor: We know that the character is a Black male, because the author refers to the character as "Him" so we know that he is male. Also at the end of the story Dwayne says " Chalk one up for the Black race", so we know that he is Black.

    ReplyDelete
  19. What is the significant value of the three legged-stool and the black box in the story? or what does the black box signify?

    ReplyDelete
  20. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  21. @Conner.O.Cross fashion101:There is no where in the story were it ever mention that women where disregard.This town, having performed this act for so many years, continues on with the tradition, with no objections or questions asked and they all seems to get along with it including the women. To me the story underlying evil, hypocrisy, and weakness of human kind.Period!

    ReplyDelete
  22. @Jennifer Roberts: She was probably referring to the past winners of her family. This is to show the readers how evil these peoples were. Even though she knew the consequences of the lottery, she did not bother to participate. She was as evil and hypocrite as the others.

    ReplyDelete
  23. Is it safe to say that Dwayne, might have been a racist or prejudice black man?

    ReplyDelete
  24. @Conner.O.Cross fashion101, the evidence shown are how both Dwayne and the old man just, measured the ladies and placed in there mind that they weren't real competition due to their physical appearance and age.

    ReplyDelete
  25. What is the author saying about Dwayne (even black people in general) when the author describes how Dwayne is not interested in the old man's book because it was set in the future?

    ReplyDelete
  26. @Robert: Considering the fact that Dwayne was the only black person in the airport, I believe he started to calculate his chances of winning because he felt as though he had the most to loose.

    ReplyDelete
  27. Why did the author wait until the end of the short-story to describe Dwayne's race?

    ReplyDelete
  28. @Lauren: While I do believe that Dwayne's race played a role in the other contestants not supporting him, I also believe that he perpetuated a stereotype of black people by dancing like MC Hammer as soon as he won. He completely forgot about the pact that they had made to support each other no matter who won.

    ReplyDelete
  29. @Francia Georges: I believe you have the wrong story. The story "The Lottery" you are talking about is what we read in class by Shirley Jackon. This story "The Lottery" is written by Paul Nixon. These are two completety different stories with the same title.

    ReplyDelete
  30. Could it be that Dwayne was so ignorant that he dismissed and underestimated three of the other four finalist by focusing more on the white man "perfection" to his own appearance why he had lost?

    ReplyDelete
  31. @Connor there is no true way to tell but out of context its safe to assume that he is

    ReplyDelete
  32. @Louis-Francois R. Moise: I don't believe that Dwayne was a racist black man, but he was very excited to win. He looked at the other characters in the story and based on their imperfections he asserted himself to be the best candidate. It had nothing to do with having a prejudice or with race, that is why I believe the author states Dwayne's race near the end of the story.

    ReplyDelete
  33. @Abigail that could be possible and very deceiving but, this story seem to be more of a lesson than a strategic and manipulatory type of story.

    ReplyDelete
  34. @Robert Freeman: I don't believe Dwayne is ignorant at all, he is strategic. He looked at the old women and thought that society would care about her. He also thinks that if "the young woman would have been a shoo-in if she were prettier." The white man was the only thing that stopped him from winning that is why he focused the most on him. Also, Dwayne did win, that is why his flight was called.

    ReplyDelete
  35. What did appearances have to do with who would win?

    ReplyDelete
  36. why did dwayne find it so important to analyze his competition

    ReplyDelete
  37. @ Robert Freeman i agree with Darnell i do not believe dwayne was racist . I do think however after he analyzed his competitors he assessed that he had this in the bag . In a sense he became ex cited and cocky

    ReplyDelete
  38. @ darnell Robin i think they author waited till the end to tell us the characters race because he wanted to keep our minds intrigued , giving us a surprise.

    ReplyDelete
  39. Do you think it was racist when the woman said "we always win"? Why or why not?

    ReplyDelete
  40. @Darnell Robin: The author waited probably because he wanted the reader to decipher on his/her own the race of this man. He did not want us to jump to conclusions based on race alone.

    ReplyDelete
  41. @ Richard: It could be a coincidence because our society is constantly stereotyping people and/or judging them. This could also have an effect on the women being cancelled out because women are often disregarded in certain matters in our society.

    ReplyDelete
  42. Seeing as how Dwayne is conscious of race relations/inequalities (Chalk one up for the Black race.”), what do you think his reaction would have been if he had heard the mother's response of, “Yes, Baby, we won. We always win.”?

    ReplyDelete
  43. @brian.daniel23: The opposite of a winner is a loser, correct? This woman, who we can infer from the story that she is White, is making it seem as though if the White race is synonymous with winning, then the Black race is synonymous with losing. There were definitely some racist undertones in the mother's comment.

    ReplyDelete
  44. @Marsalis:
    That's a profoud question! The author says that, " He’d lost interest after the man said it was set in the future – the present was all that mattered to Dwayne." Many Black people (in general, of course) focus solely on the present and not nearly enough on the future. This is evident in the fact that many Blacks, upon receiving a pay-check, will promptly run to the mall or liquor store and neglect to deposit any money into their saving's account. It is evident in the fact that Blacks will go out and purchase an old beat-up '82 Cadillac and pour large sums of cash into "fixing it up" and decking it out in 22" rims instead of investing that money on a brand new, more realiable automobile. This all goes to say that the author is using Dwayne to depict how we, Blacks, can be sometimes: we are too preoccupied focusing on the present and fail to plan for our futures.

    ReplyDelete
  45. @Whitney: I believe that he probably would not have cared if he heard the mother's response to her child. Dwayne seemed like a very proud man, and did not seem concerned with what everyone else thought about him.

    ReplyDelete
  46. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  47. Is it safe to assume that there is some racial tension in this story? Why or why not?

    ReplyDelete
  48. How was the black man able to determine how and why he would win the lottery?

    ReplyDelete
  49. Why did the woman tell her daughter that they won the lottery when Dwayne was too far to hear?

    ReplyDelete
  50. What was the significance of the man saying "Adios compadres, chalk one up for the black race?" and does the man's race have anything to do with him winning?

    ReplyDelete
  51. @justin c. smith: I do not think that the woman was black. Also, by telling her daughter that they always win whomever this "they" was did not really show the readers that she identified with him more so that they were in opposition to him.Almost as if she was saying in her mind that he won the battle but this "they" would always win the war. The woman's race was never mentioned but I think that if she was black she would not have waited until Dwayne was out earshot to tell her daughter that they always win.

    ReplyDelete
  52. @chalcia: I think that the man must play the lottery so much that he has figured out all kinds of ridiculous reasons why someone might not be chosen. Also within himself, he has made sure that no flaw can be found in him that could alter his chances for winning. It seems like some type of OCD or an addiction in him

    ReplyDelete
  53. @brian.daniel23
    The woman was being racist when she made the statement. I also believe that she was a white woman. Even though Dwayne, (the black man) won, she still went ahead and told her daughter otherwise. That obviously showed the disrespect she had towards the man and proved that she was being racist.

    ReplyDelete
  54. @Conner.O.Gross- The evidence shown that the women were being disregarded are that when Dwayne was observing the contestants he just ignored the ladies because he knew they were no competition for him. He described them all as being unattractive or too old to win.

    ReplyDelete
  55. @Alexys: I think that the woman said that statement to her daughter simply to spare the little girls feelings from being hurt.

    ReplyDelete
  56. @Chalcia Nicholas:He was able to determine how and why he would win by looking at his opponents physical appearances and also how they came across to someone who would have just seen them for the first time. He evaluated them from head to toe and then compared it to how society would see these same people and then was able to determine that he had the best chance of winning the lottery.

    ReplyDelete
  57. What type of lottery was this? I understand the airport flight was part of it and involved random selection. However, what is the lottery?

    ReplyDelete
  58. Chalcia Nicholas said...
    How was the black man able to determine how and why he would win the lottery?

    Because Atlanta was the most likely place to take a flight to. As Seattle is not the most likely place to go to.

    ReplyDelete
  59. What did the mother mean when she said "we always win"? Did that remark deal with race?

    ReplyDelete
  60. brian.daniel23 said...
    Do you think it was racist when the woman said "we always win"? Why or why not?

    No because she is right for the most part. White have more oppurtunites to succeed and 'win' in life journey. She was just making a statement off of crtian inferences and stereotypes. Being racist is to discriminate on prejudices

    ReplyDelete
  61. @ Lauren Hardy- Yes i think it was because od Dwayne's race that the contestants did not support him because to me everybody else on the bus was white and did not expect to win. Also, he was not dressed the part. He was dressed like a typical black person who travels, wearing loose fitted sweat pants, a long sleeve shirt and a baseball cap turned to the side. When he won they were a bit shocked because it was unexpected for a black man to win during that time.

    ReplyDelete
  62. Alexys. Kelly said...
    Why did the woman tell her daughter that they won the lottery when Dwayne was too far to hear?

    @Alexys. Kelly
    She did want to offend him after his statement to "chalk one up for the black race".

    ReplyDelete
  63. @ariana.gill said
    When Dwayne said "Adios compadres, chalk one up for the black race!" it showed that he was happy and enjoyed the fact that just what he said would happen, came true. He felt that by him winning, he was representing the "black race" and his winning was one point added to black people. His race had nothing to do with him winning, but his ability to narrow it down and beat the odds helped him to determine his soon to be win.

    ReplyDelete
  64. Conner.O.Cross fashion101 said...
    What evidence shows that women are being disregarded?

    @Conner.O.Cross fashion101
    The author clearly says "Once he had dismissed the ladies".

    ReplyDelete
  65. @Conner.O.Cross fashion 101 as the narrator describes how Dwayne is examining his competition he states what would have made the young woman the winner except for that one flaw that she had and why the old lady couldn't win then "after he dismissed the ladies" he focused his attention on the other man "his remaining competition."

    ReplyDelete
  66. What is the significance of "(im)patiently"?

    ReplyDelete
  67. @keon
    i believe the mother had to much pride to admit that a African American had won. so in her mind she was still the winner.. and yea i think it had some racial intentions

    ReplyDelete
  68. @connor: we dont know that he is a black man. The writer has just described all the characters but that doesn't mean that by process of ellimation we assume that he is black. He can be white. Even yellow or green.

    ReplyDelete
  69. @Alexys. Kelly
    i believe the mother told her daughter that they had won once dwayne had left because deep down she knew she was wrong and she didn't want dwayne to feel offended.

    ReplyDelete
  70. @Alexys. Kelly
    When the mother told her daughter that " we always, win"' I think it was because she believed that no matter the outcome they had learned a new lesson about life. The fact that she waited till the man could clearly not hear or see was because he would not hear her comment in the way that see meant it, and would probably think that her comment was out of jealousy.

    ReplyDelete
  71. Was the white man really trying to purchase authenticity?

    ReplyDelete
  72. @Jennifer Roberts, The mother was proud of Dwayne because they might have been the same race.

    ReplyDelete
  73. @Louis-Francois R. Moise, I don't think Dwayne was a racist. Even though what he said could be takin out of context. When he said "Chalk one up for the Black race" I think he was saying that it was finally the black races' turn to achieve something, instead of being looked down on.

    ReplyDelete
  74. Judging from the Dwayne's evaluation of the white man, what does that say about how he may operate on a day to day basis in order to "win" ?

    ReplyDelete
  75. Keon Hines said What did the mother mean when she said "we always win"? Did that remark deal with race?

    I definitely think race had something to do with the woman's comment because she waited until the "Black man" was out of earshot to say yes we won; "we always win". She meant that white people always win, whether it was a woman or man. Their race is dominant.

    ReplyDelete
  76. What do you think that Dwayne analyzed the story as indepthly as he did?

    ReplyDelete
  77. Marsalis Brown said What is the author saying about Dwayne (even black people in general) when the author describes how Dwayne is not interested in the old man's book because it was set in the future?

    Some Black people going through a hard life or have limited opportunities have a terrible habit of living in the now and living for today. Some of them live pay check to pay check just to survive. There's no 5 year plan and when there's an opportunity to get some quick money such as the lottery, their faith and hope is put into it as a way out of the hard life. So for Dwayne to not be concerned about the future is not uncommon because it happens everyday. His focus was trying to win the odds against him and be victorious in doing so.

    ReplyDelete
  78. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  79. What was the real competition these contestants were in? Was it really about who would get to go to their city or was it deeper than that?

    ReplyDelete
  80. When the woman tells her child, “Yes, Baby, we won. We always win.”, what is she referring to?

    ReplyDelete
  81. @LemontJoseph: the lottery was simply who was going to get on the plan first, the people in the story were trying to see who had the boarding pass that would get them on the plan first.

    ReplyDelete
  82. Alexys. Kelly said...
    Why did the woman tell her daughter that they won the lottery when Dwayne was too far to hear?

    I believe the woman waited until Dwayne was too far to hear to respond to her child because although she was was spiteful towards him, they had all made a silent agreement to support whoever won and she did not want it to seem as though she was breaking that pact.

    ReplyDelete
  83. Being one of five competitors, what do you believe was Dwayne's motivation towards remaining so confident about his chances of winning, given that the odds are against him?

    ReplyDelete
  84. @Janay Hanna: I believe that it is safe to say so due to the phasing and words used by the people in the story?

    ReplyDelete
  85. Whitney Hucks said...
    Seeing as how Dwayne is conscious of race relations/inequalities (Chalk one up for the Black race.”), what do you think his reaction would have been if he had heard the mother's response of, “Yes, Baby, we won. We always win.”?

    Dwayne would have been quite upset to hear this comment. Perhaps it would have lessened his win because it was not only about winning a flight, but about beating the other races. For Dwayne to find out that a woman of another race still felt as though she won, his win would have been less enjoyable.

    ReplyDelete
  86. Why is the story's title "Lottery"?

    ReplyDelete
  87. @Jennifer: the mother thinks they always win becuase of her race and how they maybe superior to all other races.

    ReplyDelete
  88. @Michaelle: in general people almost always associate appearence with sucess so when Dwayne described his opponents appearence he was giving reason as to why they wont be sucessful in winnin g.

    ReplyDelete
  89. @Keon Hines
    I am positive that the comment that the mother made to her daughter was to be viewed as racist remark- not to mention she "kindly" waited until the Black man was out of earshot. She was reminding her daughter of how they [the white race] are more superior to the others. Regardless of the outcome, they are still the winners.

    ReplyDelete
  90. @michael... i think she is refering to the patience of her spirit...and giving the same discipline to the girl!

    ReplyDelete
  91. what was so significant about the bonds created between the characters that allowed them to start calculating each other?

    ReplyDelete
  92. Nichole
    Why does the ladies description in lottery ticket make the man think that she has no chance of winning?

    ReplyDelete
  93. Conner.O.Cross fashion101 because the women states it at the end of the story.

    ReplyDelete
  94. @Keon The evidence that shows that women were disregarded was when he talks about how she wasn't pretty enough. Making it seem like there is a standrad of beauty that a women has to live to to even be recognized.

    ReplyDelete
  95. LemontJoseph yes I believe she is being racist because the mentality now a days is that whites always have the upper hand in society and they always succeed over the minority

    ReplyDelete
  96. @ Shawna. throughout the story we can conclude that they were battling for a seat on a flight and in a lotto game, competitors battle for money. A comparison can be made between the lotto and this story to see who will be victorious

    ReplyDelete
  97. Earleen Waldron

    The Narrator said that Dwayne began to dance MC Hammer style. What was the significance of comparing Dwayne to MC Hammer?

    ReplyDelete
  98. From Dwayne's description of his competitors, how would u describe his personality and his character?

    ReplyDelete
  99. What does Dwayne's descriiptions of the other competitors imply about what society around him values?
    EN 112- 11

    ReplyDelete
  100. Q: Hopal.Mel said...
    what was so significant about the bonds created between the characters that allowed them to start calculating each other?

    A: The bond was created because the competitors saw the need to be friends in order to win the trust of the others. The bond allowed them to take down defenses and better calculate if the others were competition or not.

    Q: Alexys. Kelly said...
    Why did the woman tell her daughter that they won the lottery when Dwayne was too far to hear?

    A: She did it because she didn't want the Black man to know that he actually lost. She wanted him to be happy in his "apparent victory", because something bad was in store for him or there was an alternative motive in the contest.

    ReplyDelete
  101. @justin c. smith...You asked if the woman could be Black herself and if that why is why she identified with the Black man by telling her daughter they won?
    To look from this perspective, there is a possibility that the lady could be black, but she was possibly ashamed of Dwayne. In the story it states " began to dance MC Hammer-style directly in front of his defeated competition." Another part of the story explains that Dwayne was dressed in sweats etc. His appearance and seemingly cocky attitude could have caused the mother to want to disassociate herself with the black man. She could be ashamed of her race, and in Dwayne doing these sterotypical "black acts" she did not want Dwayne to know or possibly hear that she was supportive of him, his win, and their race.

    ReplyDelete
  102. @Michaelle...you asked what appearances had to do with who would win. I believe people in society are taught or conformed to certian social standards, expected behavior, and conditioned to think a certain way. We are also in this category if you think about it. Thats why were able to all sit down in a class and pay attention, instead of climbing up on the chairs, yelling etc. In this story the people are also conditioned. In society your race, appearance, ethinicity etc have a lot to do with how people will treat you, and what they will think of you. The way the people looked in the story caused Dwayne to judge and analyze them, from their race, to their appearance etc. If the narrator was explaining what everyone else was thinking, there would probably be similar thoughts from the others.

    ReplyDelete
  103. Does the format of the story (the way it is written) have any impact on the story? Explain.

    ReplyDelete
  104. Does this story intend for its reader to consider all the things that are done as a gamble? Ex. (relying on man-made objects to make life worthwhile; working with nuclear chemicals..etc.)

    ReplyDelete
  105. @Jennifer Roberts: The mother may have seen herself as always winning because she may have acquired frequent flyer-miles before she traveled with her dauther, thus giving her the opportunity to fly as much as she wanted.

    ReplyDelete
  106. @Robert Chiles: I don't think the mother was teaching her dauther discrimination or giving her a sense of superiority because she wouldn't have sat close to the guy for hours, giving that inferior people wouldn't have the same kind of chairs for example, to sit on. And on-top of that, the guy did get his flight before they did.

    ReplyDelete
  107. How did the five people become finalists? What happened to the others that were at the airport?

    ReplyDelete
  108. @Justin: The woman was not black because in the story it says that she had "no streaks in her natural blond hair" which means that she may have been white. So she said "Black man" to make a distinction between her and him.

    ReplyDelete
  109. @Shanna: The story is titled "Lottery" because of the five people who were waiting on their flight number to be called. It is just like a real lottery when you are waiting for the numbers you picked to be called.

    ReplyDelete
  110. @Jennifer Roberts: The mother was trying to teach her daughter a sense of entitlement. She was also trying to build a foundation that taught her daughter that she always comes out as a winner.

    ReplyDelete
  111. is this how racisim is born? what should we do to correct this situation and how can we reverse the mothers doing?

    ReplyDelete
  112. @Connor.O.Cross: We know the character is a Black man because the author tells us at the end of the story.

    ReplyDelete
  113. @Keon
    The woman felt as if she had entitlement to the situation. She considers her and her daughter to be superior beings because of their color and who they are. She was obviously taught by her parents the same awful thing she is teaching her impressionable daughter.

    ReplyDelete
  114. @Connor.O.Cross: We can determine the character is African American because the writer tells us and the racist comment the lady makes as he walked away.

    ReplyDelete
  115. Was the lottery actually a competition to see who would actually board the plane first?

    ReplyDelete
  116. @sheldon3030 . We can safely assume that the white man was trying to purchase authenticity because he was caught up in many expensive personal items. The white man was probably using money to make himself feel socially acceptable when he's actually insecure.

    ReplyDelete
  117. @nichole. Dwayne rules out the woman from winning the lottery contest because she didn't have the looks to win such a competition. Dwayne doesn't think the woman with the baby wasn't that attractive therefore she didn't have a chance at winning.

    ReplyDelete
  118. How did the slightly shifted hair piece of the well dressed man show he was trying to fit in?

    ReplyDelete
  119. @Jennifer Roberts
    I think the mother was trying to either comfort her daughter, you how sometimes parents tell there kids things so they don't feel bad, or she was saying as a Caucasian person, they were and will always be superior and win.

    ReplyDelete
  120. @Joy Chikwekwe
    I think it was simply about whose flight would come first.

    ReplyDelete
  121. so since Dewayne victory was not the winning prize he thinks it will be, what will it be? "but because he was consumed with thoughts of his apparent victory he heard nothing."

    ReplyDelete
  122. @Tgrant i do not believe the competition was to see who would board the plane

    ReplyDelete
  123. @ Nicole Morrison maybe because the black race tends to celebrate prematurely of for the wrong reasons all the time.

    ReplyDelete
  124. Why is it that Dwane won apparently but not realisticly?

    ReplyDelete
  125. @sheldon3030 I think its safe to say that he was trying to buy his authenticity because he had a lot of material things and he was dressed very nicely while everyone else was dressed normal.

    ReplyDelete
  126. @Danielle Lewis It implies that society is corrupt

    ReplyDelete
  127. If a racist society is being implied, why would the Black man even hope for victory among white opponents?

    ReplyDelete
  128. @Nicole Morrison: The character's race is significant to highlight the theme of racism in the story.

    ReplyDelete
  129. @Michael: The young woman tells her daughter they always win to highlight a popular, racist belief that Caucasians are superior.

    ReplyDelete